Top 25 Iconic Comic Book Covers That Aren’t Key Issues
by
IzzyVerseNYC
|April 15, 2025
Sometimes, it's not about the first appearance—it's about the unforgettable image on the front.
When people think of key comics, it's usually tied to a first appearance, a death, or a major moment in continuity. But what about those comics that never became “keys” but still stuck with us thanks to their incredible cover art?
In this Creator Spotlight, we’re highlighting 25 of the most iconic comic book covers that earned their fame through powerful visuals, memorable character moments, and flat-out great design. These books may not hold key status, but their covers have become collector favorites, wall-worthy, and sometimes surprisingly affordable.
Along the way, we’ll touch on market values and what makes each cover stand the test of time.
Tales to Astonish #93 (1967, Marvel) Cover by Marie Severin Hulk meets Silver Surfer in a dynamic and explosive moment of classic Marvel muscle.
Fantastic Four #72 (1968, Marvel) Cover by Jack Kirby A powerful cosmic image featuring Silver Surfer in one of Kirby’s finest outer-space scenes.
These covers may not come with the big label of "key issue," but they’ve proven to be just as desirable for fans and collectors alike. Whether it's the art, the vibe, or the moment it captures, each one of these deserves a place in comic book history—and maybe even in your collection.
If you want to hear our take on these 25 iconic covers, check out the YouTube video we put together—it’s a fun one you won’t want to miss!
Which ones are your favorites? Did I miss any non-key iconic cover? Let us know!
